“Arnold, Shirley Jackson wants me to go against your sexist and evil traditions!”
Sometimes students compose sentences that stop me. I read and reread them with appreciation and silent applause. Sometimes, not so silent. Sometimes, I copy and paste what a student wrote to my own social media bragging FOR them and about them. Proud, proud, proud. Sometimes I read them aloud to my husband and my father because they’re my ‘captive audience’ when I’m grading. (Earlier, I complained about a piece I was grading, and my father, bless his sweet heart, said, ‘You chose this.’ Very reminiscent of my daughter Kennedy’s response when I might feel a bit frustrated about grading. To him, I said, “Okay, Kennedy.” Ha. But, he was right.) This particular copy-pasted piece, however, from a student’s essay, is an entire conclusion paragraph that made me laugh. And because it made me laugh, I must share that laugh with you. So, for anyone who appreciates Shirley Jackson, I present my Comp I student’s concluding paragraph for her rhetorical analysis of “The Lottery.”
“As a story, ‘The Lottery’ is objectively gut-wrenching and horrifying. Why would anyone want to read a story about murder? You want to read a story about murder because it will make you understand that tradition is not always right. When Uncle Arnold shouts at the annual Christmas party, “Little Janie, why are you a plumber? That is a man’s job?,” you can shout back, “Arnold, Shirley Jackson wants me to go against your sexist and evil traditions. She is a critically acclaimed author, by the way!” You might not be named Janie or have an Uncle Arnold, but you do experience evil traditions that “The Lottery” helps you understand. By skillfully using ethos, logos, and pathos, she exposes the dangers of blind conformity and challenges readers to examine the traditions they accept. The story serves as a powerful reminder that just because something has always been done does not mean it should continue.”
If you haven’t read “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, do so. Then, read a biography or two about Shirley’s life. Then, read “The Lottery” again. You’ll discover that not only is this author saying not to continue blindly following traditions, but she also is SCREAMING to the reader – “Don’t be trapped!” See, she was a trapped woman. She lived a life of abuse from childhood through her marriage, and her ‘cage’ killed her at the age of 48. Heart disease. It is a scientific fact that stress, anxiety, and fear have a direct correlation to heart disease. Shirley died at age 48. This woman, whose life was plagued with stress, anxiety, and fear, is SCREAMING to the audience, “Don’t be trapped like me!”
This touches me deeply. I was 51 when my heart almost gave out. 51 when I had open-heart surgery … much too young, but that is what a life lived in stress will get you. No more of that in what remains of my days here in this life; each day is an opportunity to share my experience, strength, and hope. Each day I pray, “God, may I be of use to YOU today.” Then, I step into the day, live in the moment, and shine, shine, shine.
I also echo Shirley … “Don’t be trapped!” Think. Explore. Laugh. LIVE. Go against the FLOW. Or, like my student wrote, say, “Arnold, Shirley Jackson wants me to go against your sexist and evil traditions!”
I flippin’ love how the student wove in that Uncle Arnold and Little Janie bit. Hilarious – and powerful. Nicely done, my student. Nicely done.

